Tin Whisker Mitigation Methodologies: Report from SMART Group, Part 1


Reading time ( words)

In order of preference, common mitigation practices included non-tin plating, for example nickel-palladium-gold finish, as used by Texas Instruments but not many other component manufacturers, adding lead or bismuth to the tin plating, using a nickel underlayer or annealing tin plating at 150°C for one hour within 24 hours of plating, although this would be acceptable only when accompanied by supporting test data. Other viable mitigation practices were hot-dip tinning for structural steel parts, or hot-oil fused tin plating. Finishes to be avoided were silver, plated tin-copper, any tin plating over brass without a copper or nickel barrier, and bright tin.

CharlesCawthorne-SMARTGroup.jpgCawthorne reviewed the definitions of the mitigation control levels defined in GEIA-STD-0005-2, commenting that the required level would normally be a function of the design authority in consultation with the customer, and that military applications would typically expect mitigation to at least Level 2B—risks managed primarily through mitigations, including design rules, and more likely 2C—risks managed more by avoidance and less by mitigation. Level 3 managed whisker risks through complete avoidance. He went on to discuss the detail requirements of Levels 2B, 2C and 3, with particular reference to the use of conformal coatings to form a physical barrier. The defining standard for tin whisker susceptibility of tin and tin alloy surface finishes was JEDEC JESD201A, an accelerated test used by component manufacturers, but there was some doubt as to the reliability of results since tin whiskering was such an unpredictable phenomenon.

In summary, as the standards had evolved, they had become increasingly definitive with regard to component-to-component spacing design rules. There had been a move away from component termination material type, structure and processing as specific mitigation strategies. Strategies were now based on protective barriers, re-finishing of component terminations, and automatic coverage of pure tin finished surfaces by tin-lead solder during the assembly process.

MartinWickham-SMARTGroup.jpgA series of collaborative projects had been carried out at the National Physical Laboratory to evaluate conformal coating as a tin whisker mitigation strategy for printed circuit assemblies. Martin Wickham reviewed previous findings and gave an update on current work. Using a tin plating process deliberately chosen for it high propensity to whiskering, NPL had developed a parallel plate test vehicle that had been enabled electrical detection of failure. One observation was that failure predominantly occurred at the edges of plates, where full coating thickness was not maintained around the right angle bend, and this geometry was a characteristic feature of component leads. An additional test vehicle had been designed, based on a PCB with 24 SOIC14 packages, assembled using range of techniques, to enable testing for short circuits between adjacent leads on individual component. Each batch of eight boards was delivered to consortium partners for coating and returned to NPL for testing. The assemblies were constantly monitored at a test voltage of 15 volts with a series resistor to limit current to 15 milliamps.

Nine batches had been built to date, together with control assemblies with no coating, all of which had shown extensive whiskering before any evidence was seen on the coated examples. Using the analogue of two sword-fencers for illustration, Wickham explained different failure modes: intermittent shorts involving more than one whisker, and longer shorts penetrating out through the coating in one position and back in through the coating elsewhere. He showed several examples of actual failures, and other instances where whiskers had grown but not yet been detected electrically. It was intended to continue ageing the test vehicles and review failures after a further six months, and to visually inspect the assemblies again after twelve months, also to build control assemblies to investigate the effect of temperature during coating. Possible future work would investigate the effects of vibration and forced air cooling.

In Part 2, SMART Group Steering Committee member Ian Fox, Micross Components’ Mark Walmsley, and more words from Dr Mark Ashworth.

Share

Print


Suggested Items

Comparing Soldering Results of ENIG and EPIG Post-steam Exposure

09/11/2019 | Jon Bengston and Richard DePoto, Uyemura International USA
Electroless nickel immersion gold (ENIG) is now a well-regarded finish used to enhance and preserve the solderability of copper circuits. Electroless palladium immersion gold (EPIG), meanwhile, is a new surface finish also for enhancing and preserving solderability—but with the advantage of eliminating electroless nickel from the deposit layer. This feature has become increasingly important with the increasing use of high-frequency PCB designs whereby nickel’s magnetic properties are detrimental.

Solder Mask Evolves into a Truly Additive Process

09/09/2019 | John Fix, Taiyo America Inc.
The 5G era is creating quite a bit of work for many PCB engineers as the materials required to keep up with the speed, frequency, and latency requirements need to be defined and qualified. Solder mask, for example, now becomes a truly additive process. Read on to find out how and why.

Selecting the Proper Flex Coverlayer Material

09/06/2019 | Dave Lackey, American Standard Circuits
Coverlayers are polymer materials used to cover and protect the copper traces of the flex circuit product. There are a number of different options available for protecting the circuits, and they serve different design requirements in terms of cost, performance, and flexural endurance optimization. When specifying the choice, it is critical to call out not just the type of coverlayer material but also the thickness requirement. This can be very important in certain types of constructions, especially when a flex circuit will experience dynamic flexing during use.



Copyright © 2019 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.