Voiding Control at High-Power Die-Attach Preform Soldering

Reading time ( words)

Assembly of components with large pads, such as high-brightness LEDs or high-power dies, often is soldered with preforms. Solder preforms are used to lower voiding and to lower flux fumes that can be generated by solder paste. The use of solder preforms also result in better thermal and electrical conductivity compared to Ag epoxy. This is particularly true when the joints are to be formed within a cavity.

Voiding in the solder joint is a concern for high-reliability and high-performance devices. In this study, voiding behavior of large pad high-power devices was simulated with copper (Cu) coupon to Cu coupon sandwiches. A flux-coated preform was studied in this assembly, with variation in solder alloy type, quantity of solid flux coated on solder preform, Cu coupon pre-oxidation extent, reflow temperature, and pressure exerted onto the sandwich during reflow.


1. Solder Alloy Type

Preforms of three solder alloys were tested: 96.5Sn/3Ag/0.5Cu (SAC305), 63Sn/37Pb, and 57Bi/42Sn/1Ag. The preform diameter was 0.906-inch, and 0.006-inch thick.

2. Flux Coating

The preform was pre-coated with a solid flux film using liquid flux at 0.5, 1.0, and 2% flux concentrations in isopropyl alcohol upon application.

3. Cu Coupon Oxidation Pre-treatment

The copper coupon (0.906-inch diameter, 0.020-inch thick) was used to simulate both die and substrate. It was pre-cleaned by soaking in a diluted HBF4 aqueous solution, followed by deionized water rinsing, and air drying. These cleaned Cu coupons were then oxidized by placing them on a 230°C hot plate for 0, 30, and 60 seconds, and five minutes prior to the soldering process.

4. Die-Attach Sandwich Setup

The high-power die-attach setup was simulated with the use of two Cu coupons, which were to be joined with a flux-coated solder preform. A 3-inch x 3-inch ceramic plate was used as a carrier. The simulated die-attach sandwich (Cu coupon on a solder preform, then placed on another Cu coupon) was placed on the carrier. At die-attach with solder preforms, many manufacturing processes use fixtures with some weight on the die to secure the sandwich. In this study, metal weight varying from 0 to 100 grams was placed on the top of the sandwich to simulate the fixture weight. Paper cardboard was placed on top of the die for heat insulation, if a weight was used.

5. Reflow Peak Temperature

The sandwich on the carrier was placed on a 5-zone, in-line contact reflow oven, and then sent through the reflow oven with various peak temperatures as follows:

  • SAC305: 240°C, 250°C, and 260°C
  • 63Sn/37Pb: 205°C, 215°C, and 225°C
  • 57Bi/42Sn/1Ag: 160°C, 170°C, and 180°C

6. Reflow Under Various Pressures

For SAC305, various weights were placed on top of the sandwiches at reflow: 0, 10, 30, and 100 grams. For this set of assembly, freshly cleaned Cu coupons, 0.5% flux concentration, and a peak temperature of 240°C were used. Ten sandwiches were reflowed for each condition. For 63Sn/37Pb and 57Bi/42Sn/1Ag, 0, 10, 20, and 30 grams of weight were used for the pressure study.

7. Assessment

After reflow, the sandwiches were examined under X-ray to determine the voiding area percentage. For SAC305, three sandwiches for each weight condition were cross-sectioned to determine the bondline thickness under various weights


Effect of Weight on SAC305 System Using X-ray Images

Indium-Figure 1-Apr2017.jpg

Figure 1 shows the X-ray images of SAC305 sandwiches under various weights. Here, the flux concentration was 0.5%, the peak temperature was 240°C, and the coupons were etch-cleaned prior to use. Although 10 samples were prepared for each combination of conditions, three sandwiches were removed due to large opens in the solder joints because the image analysis software was unable to determine the voiding percentage properly. Most of the samples showed full wetting to the perimeter of coupons, and only a few showed a small fraction of non-wetting near the edge of the joints.

Figure 1: X-ray images for SAC305 soldered sandwiches processed with various weights on top of samples.

Most of the voids showed plain vacancy, except for a few samples where some spotty light-colored solder were seen within the voids, such as in the third image of the 10-gram series and the first image of the 30-gram series. The spotty solder islands were attributed to the once-formed liquid joints, but were wiped out partially by expanding voids.

In most images, concentric ring textures can be seen clearly, indicating the Cu coupons may be warped. Also, the joint appeared to be thicker toward the center, and the solidification may have been developed stepwise from the edge toward the center.

1. Bondline Thickness (BLT): The 100-gram weight samples showed a much lighter shade of color than the other three weight samples, suggesting much thinner solder BLT data for SAC305 joints under various weights. The sandwich samples were cross-sectioned, as exemplified in Figure 2, with the BLT measured at both the edges and the center. The average value was calculated to represent the BLT of a given weight condition.


Suggested Items

Manufacturability: Pad Relief and Mask Relationship to Solder Joint Volume

03/09/2018 | Ken Horky, Peterson Manufacturing
Electronic assembly thermal management has always been an issue but has become more significant as we pack more power and function into a smaller form factor. In recent years, the growing use of LEDs for illumination on a large scale has presented additional thermal demands.

PCB Pad Repair Techniques

01/08/2018 | Bob Wettermann, BEST Inc.
There are a variety of reasons behind pads getting "lifted" completely or partially from the laminate of a PCB. Per the just revised IPC-A-610 Revision G, a defect for all three classes occurs when the land is lifted up one or more pad thicknesses. Lifted pads can occur when a device has been improperly removed or there is a manufacturing defect in the board construction. In any case, as with any repair, the ultimate decision on the ability to repair the pad lies with the customer.

Focus on the New

01/05/2018 | Stephen Las Marias, I-Connect007
It seems like it wasn't too long ago when I was writing about the optimism of the electronics manufacturing and assembly industry going into 2017. Now, here we are again at the beginning of the new year, looking at new trends, disruptive technologies, and emerging markets for 2018. I am also proud to announce our new branding as well as our fresh, new look.

Copyright © 2018 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.