2D X-ray Inspection With Materials and Thickness Identification

Reading time ( words)


X-ray inspection systems are key tools for quality control, yield enhancement, and failure analysis of PCBs and semiconductor devices. In many cases, these capable tools provide the only non-destructive techniques for inspection of electronic components. There have been significant improvements in the X-ray inspection capabilities (both 2D and 3D) in the last several years. In this paper we report a new development that permits material and thickness information to be obtained via 2D X-ray inspection.

While absorption contrast X-ray imaging is a very powerful inspection technique, it does not exploit all of the information present within the X-ray beam transmitted through a sample. A new technology has been recently developed that, instead of simply measuring the total absorption of the X-ray beam, also enables changes in the beam energy to be resolved. This allows the effects of thickness and density to be decoupled, enabling both to be determined. This quantitative composition and thickness information can then be used to provide new levels of insight in PCB and semiconductor inspection, potentially leading the way to a new generation of X-ray inspection technology.

It is quite straightforward to accommodate this technology in an existing 2D X-ray (2DX) inspection system. Advanced software algorithms need to be incorporated and an intuitive user interface is provided.

We present an overview of this new technology and give examples of other industries where this technology is being adopted, as well as example applications for the PCB and semiconductor industries.


The need to inspect electronic components and assemblies non-destructively is the main driver behind the development and advancement of the X-ray inspection technology for the electronics industry. In many cases, X-Ray inspection (2D and 3D) provides the only non-destructive techniques to inspect optically hidden components and solder joints such as BGA, POP, QFN, flip chips, through holes, TSVs, microbumps, copper pillars, etc.

All X-ray inspection systems (2D and 3D) rely on absorption contrast imaging, where the contrast is generated by the stopping power of the sample. As such, higher density and/or thicker regions of a sample produce darker regions in a grey-scale image. X-ray inspection systems use this method to image features such as wire bonds and ball grid arrays down to a feature recognition size of 100 nm (0.1 μm).

While contrast imaging is a very powerful and widely used technique, there is significantly more information present within the X-ray beam, which, until now, has not been exploited in electronics inspection. Instead of simply measuring the total absorption of the X-ray beam, a physical structure known as a multi absorption plate (MAP) can be placed in the beam path. This, coupled with machine learning algorithms, enables material type and thickness information to be acquired alongside the standard grey-scale image.

Quantitative composition and thickness information can then be used to provide more detailed diagnostics in PCB and semiconductor inspection. Applications include, but are not limited to, analysis of solder types, track thickness measurements, and conformance to quality standards.

An overview of the theory behind the operation of the MAP is given below, as well as some simple examples showing the benefits of using the MAP technology to add additional capabilities to 2D X-Ray inspection. MAP technology also has applications in the security, medical and food processing industries. Nordson Dage has partnered with IBEX to bring the benefits of this technology to the electronics inspection, including inspection of PCBs and semiconductor devices. A range of examples is presented and the authors aim to start active discussions that would generate new needs and ideas for use of the technology for non-destructive inspection of electronics systems and components.


X-ray Interaction with a Sample

X-rays are generated using a tungsten target which produces a continuous spectrum, known as Bremβtrahlung radiation, as well as characteristic peaks at specific energies.

Adding a sample such as a printed circuit board into the beam attenuates the X-ray spectrum in the following way:

I(E) = I0(E)exp(-µ(E)t)                       (1)

where I0(E) and I(E) are the intensities of the X-ray spectra before and after the sample, respectively; µ(E) is the material-dependent linear attenuation coefficient; and t is the thickness of the sample.

If I0(E) and I(E) can be determined, it is possible to extract the parameter µ(E) which relates to the material type and the material thickness.

A standard CMOS detector integrates the total energy deposited into each pixel over the user-selected integration time. As such, the detector is able to measure total energy deposited per pixel but not the actual energy spectrum. This means that it is not possible to decouple the material and thickness terms in equation (1), meaning that thin, high density materials are indistinguishable from thick, low density materials in a single 2D projection.

The Multi Absorption Plate (MAP) acts like a complex color filter for the X-rays by imposing a repeating modulation to the X-ray beam over a few neighboring pixels. This modulation results in a variation in the energy distribution of the X-ray beam incident on the neighboring pixels in a way that enables unique materials information to be obtained.

Extracting Materials Information—Simple Examples

IBEX-Figure 1-Jun2017.jpg

Figure 1 shows the word IBEX constructed using a series of copper tiles with a background made up of foils of silver. The thicknesses of the foils have been selected in order to randomize the grey-scale intensity transmitted by the tiles and hence obscure the word IBEX in a standard X-ray image. Analyzing the image with a MAP in place recovers the materials information. The intensities of the coloring in the bottom image of Figure 1 reflect the relative thicknesses of the tiles.

Figure 1: Optical image showing the word IBEX created as a mosaic of random thicknesses of silver and copper foils (top); X-ray transmission image showing that it is not possible to distinguish between the foils using absorption contrast alone (middle); materials contrast image showing that the missing information can be recovered using the MAP (bottom).

This materials information can be displayed to the user in terms of a basic mask identifying the materials, as an overlay of material identification on the absorption contrast image, or in the case of automated quality inspection systems as a pass/fail criterion.



Suggested Items

SMTA Europe Solder Finish Webinar Addresses Defects Causes and Cures

12/14/2020 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007
“What is your most common PCB problem?” A survey conducted by Bob Willis had revealed finish solderability to be the predominant contender, and it was clear that the choice of solderable finish applied to surface mount boards could have a significant effect on the assembly yield and cost of the final circuit. SMTA Europe organised an informative and enlightening webinar this month entitled “Guide to PCB Solder Finishes—Process Defects Causes and Cures,” with soldering specialist Bob Willis as presenter.

Reducing Flux Splatter in Sensors and Camera Modules

10/30/2020 | Jasbir Bath, Shantanu Joshi, and Noriyoshi Uchida, Koki Solder America And Koki Company Limited
With the increased use of electronics in new technology areas, flux formulations are being developed to address the new and existing requirements. For sensors and camera modules used for Advanced Driver Assistance System (ADAS) and internet of things (IoT) applications, there is a demand for no-clean flux formulations in lead-free solder paste, which can reduce flux splattering during reflow.

How to Benefit From Robotic Soldering Processes

10/28/2020 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007
Webinars are in vogue! But in Pete Starkey's experience, the master of the technical webinar with many years’ experience of delivering first-rate events is Bob Willis—electronics assembly specialist, soldering expert, and provider of training and consultancy in electronics manufacture. Here, Pete recaps Bob’s presentation on the upcoming robotic soldering experience.

Copyright © 2021 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.