An Alternative Approach to Vertical Integration in Manufacturing

Reading time ( words)

The past 50 years have seen the emergence of the EMS industry as OEMs outsourced increasingly more of their product to various global contract manufacturers. Originally concentrated in the United States, the industry has blossomed into nearly $600 billion in sales and their growth shows no indication of slowing in the near future.

The EMS industry was fed by acquisitions of manufacturing concerns from OEMs in the 1990s, followed by mergers of many EMS players in the 2000s. The worldwide manufacturing landscape has changed forever. The days of OEMs owning large vertically integrated manufacturing assets are gone and will probably never return. Oddly, the large vertically integrated manufacturing capability of the OEMs started to be dismantled by the emergence of the EMS companies. Now, some of these same EMS companies are adopting the same, vertically integrated solutions themselves.

Changes in EMS—ODM & Vertical Integration

Even within the EMS world, the past 10 years have witnessed two significant changes. First, there was the emergence of the original design manufacturer (ODM) as third parties participated more in the design and engineering of product on behalf of the OEMs, and then the merger of the ODM capability into the EMS players either through acquisitions or in-house development of the capability. Second, there was the broadening of manufacturing capability within EMS through vertical integration. Again, the vertical integration originated from the EMS’ acquisition of existing technology manufacturers (such as metal fabrication and plastic injection molding) or the in-house development of the capability.


The ODM factor immediately draws in the unwanted complication of intellectual property (IP) rights and protection of them. The fear of losing IP to competitors through undisciplined or unscrupulous ODMs is sufficient to justify customers’ staying clear of EMS partners who rely heavily on this capability for revenue. The larger Tier 1 EMS players are heavily invested in customers with consumer products where small design developments can be a differentiation, but the life cycle of their product is so short, the need to maintain intellectual property security is less critical. However, these same Tier-1 players have some customers who are not part of the consumer market yet the financial support of the ODM infrastructure within the Tier 1’s corporate structure is still burdened over the broader base of their corporate costs. MC Assembly prefers to invest in engineering resources dedicated specifically to processes like design for manufacturability (DFM) and design for excellence (DFX) where the output is not directly sold to its customer, but rather their customer benefits from the associated cost reductions gained from the improved efficiencies in the manufacturing processes.

Vertical Integration in EMS

The vertical integration factor is a little less straightforward. Initially, the movement towards vertical integration of manufacturing capability was limited to the exceptionally large EMS companies and, at first, was usually the result of them acquiring an auxiliary manufacturing capability as part of the acquisition of circuit board assembly and surface mount technology (SMT) from an OEM.


Figure 1: MC Assembly process lines demonstrating high-complexity mechatronics assemblies. Note the metal fabrication and cables that are fed from MC integrated partners.



Suggested Items

Excerpt: The Printed Circuit Assembler’s Guide to… Smart Data, Chapter 2

04/21/2021 | Sagi Reuven and Zac Elliott, Siemens Digital Industries Software
Companies have been collecting data in large volumes. Highly varied data from manufacturing operations comes in quickly that needs to be validated, and its value prioritized so that it can be turned into something useful—transformed from big data to smart data. The amount of data available has grown exponentially into big data. Twenty years ago, a PCB work order resulted in 100 data records, megabytes of data; today, it is 10 billion records, terabytes of data. The investment in collecting this data and storing it is high. However, without a way to analyze the data, without analytics, it will not result in ROI.

Excerpt: The Printed Circuit Assembler’s Guide to… Smart Data

04/07/2021 | Sagi Reuven and Zac Elliott, Siemens Digital Industries Software
Whenever we discuss data, keep in mind that people have been collecting data, verifying it, and translating it into reports for a long time. And if data is collected and processes are changed automatically, people still will be interpreting and verifying the accuracy of the data, creating reports, making recommendations, solving problems, tweaking, improving, and innovating. Whatever data collection system is used, any effort to digitalize needs to engage and empower the production team at the factory. Their role is to attend to the manufacturing process but also to act as the front line of communications and control.

What Makes a Great Supply Chain Manager?

04/05/2021 | Timothy McLean, TXM Lean Solutions
Building a competitive and reliable supply chain is a critical success factor for any manufacturing business. This is especially true today, where we face constant volatility and disruption across global supply chains. In this environment, effective supply chain leadership is more critical than ever. So, what makes a great supply chain manager?

Copyright © 2021 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.