Top Five BGA Challenges to Overcome

Reading time ( words)

BGA component package dimensions continue to get thinner as more are being used in handheld device applications. End-use device requirements include the need to maintain their interconnections, even when dropped, thus necessitating underfill. The increased demand for higher board densities requires neighboring or mirrored devices during the rework process to be more challenging. Higher reflow temperatures of lead-free rework increases the pressure for properly shielding the neighboring components. These developments are causing BGA rework challenges. This summary will discuss the most challenging aspects of BGA rework and options for solutions.

1. Warped BGAs

Wettermann_Fig1_Sep2017.jpgFigure 1: Head-in-pillow defect.

One of the challenges in reworking BGAs at this time is the warping of the packages as ever thinner packages lead to a variety of problems. A largely noted issue of a warped BGA is the ‘Head in Pillow’ (HiP) defect (Figure 1). This defect may or may not be detectable during the X-Ray inspection. In this solder joint defect, the solder paste deposit will wet the pad, but does not fully wet the ball. This is due to the ball of the package being ‘pulled away’ during the device warping. The result is a solder joint with enough of a connection to have electrical integrity, but not sufficient mechanical strength.

Without the strength, these components may fail with a small amount of mechanical or thermal stress. This potentially costly defect is not usually detected in functional testing but rather in the field after the assembly has been exposed to some physical or thermal stresses. Warping can also cause bridging and shorts, at either the outer corners or the center of the device during replacement (Figure 2). This warping phenomenon can cause the center of the BGA to bow upwards and the corners down, or vice versa. Sometimes, this is enough to cause the corners to move closer to the circuit board surface. This puts extra pressure on the corner solder joints. Later in the lifecycle of the device, this may cause shorts or cracks.

There are several fine tunings of the rework process which will mitigate the impact of warped packages. The main way to lessen the impact of warping includes the adjustment of the reflow profile and solder paste chemistry. The reflow profile will help determine which areas of the device may be subject to thermal stress as well as ensuring the flux activity level does not expire. The solder paste chemistry is an integral step in making sure there is plenty of flux activity if the warping occurs over a prolonged reflow cycle. These variables are important to control during the BGA rework process to minimize warping.


Figure 2: Warpage and Z-height deflection on BGA.

By aiming for a very small temperature differential across the entire BGA package—less than 10°C across the entire package is optimal—the impact of device warpage can be greatly reduced in the rework process. One of the methods for ensuring a consistent and small temperature gradient across the entire package is to use a programmable multi-zone bottom-side heating source. Ideally, a multi-zoned heating source will heat the underside of the board to 100–120°C (lead-free processing temperatures) with the device location elevated to 140°C if the board and components can withstand this. This slight temperature differential will ensure that there is not undo thermal stress, which may delaminate or warp the board. The heating nozzle (assuming hot gas is used as the reflow source) will bring the solder balls up to 20–30°C above liquidus for 60–120 seconds.

In addition to the proper removal and reflow profile, the PCB will need to be properly supported to mitigate any effects of deflections on the PCB during the removal or reflow profiles. Board supports should be such that they prevent undue board deflections. The lack of support further exacerbates warping which may occur.

Solder paste chemistry can impact the degree to which the device or PCB is warped during the rework process. Solder pastes, with an activation system that can provide sustainable high-temperature fluxing, can create a homogenous connection. This connection goes beyond the ball and the paste alloy interface, which is important for warped devices to form an intermetallic bond. Those that are not able to sustain high-temperature efficacy are more prone to HiP defects.

2. Neighboring Device Damage

As the density of components on PCBs has increased, the need to protect neighboring temperature sensitive components near the BGA such as ceramic capacitors, crystals and plastic-bodied components such as connectors has increased. These devices must be protected from exposure to heat during the rework process. If they are not, they can become damaged showing either visible or ‘hidden’ damage. In addition, these components’ long-term reliability may be impacted by this heat exposure, even if their appearance does not show it. While these components may be able to withstand the peak temperature of 260°C (as defined in J-STD-002), there may be medium and long-term impacts to its reliability if the IMC layer grows too thick. Neighboring underfilled parts may have the material ‘ooze out’ as the softening point temperature is below the liquidus temperature of lead-free solder.

To read the full version of this article, which appeared in the September 2017 issue of SMT Magazine, click here.


Suggested Items

Under the Hood: Solder Joint Reliability

05/21/2018 | Burton Carpenter, NXP Semiconductors Inc.
It has been long established that packages using NSMD BGA pads were more resilient than ones with SMD pads to fatigue-induced solder joint cracks. However, NSMD pads in previous investigations on 292MAPBGA and 416PBGA packages failed sooner in AATS testing due to an alternate failure mode: substrate Cu trace cracks. This article looks into the effects of substrate material and package pad design on solder joint reliability of 0.8 mm pitch BGA.

Solving Reliability and Thermal Management Challenges in Automotive Electronics

05/01/2018 | Stephen Las Marias, I-Connect007
Paul Salerno, global portfolio manager for SMT assembly solutions at Alpha Assembly Solutions, discusses the growing automotive electronics industry, its impact on the soldering materials business, and how Alpha helps customers address the new challenges and requirements in the automotive market.

Investigating Analytical Tools for Testing Cleanliness with Foresite's Eric Camden

04/19/2018 | Patty Goldman, I-Connect007
At the recent West Penn SMTA Expo, Eric Camden, lead investigator at Foresite Inc., speaks with I-Connect007's Patty Goldman about fluxes and analytical tools for testing cleanliness, and how these impact the reliability of the assembled boards.

Copyright © 2018 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.