Two Prevalent Rework Heating Methods--Which One is Best?

Reading time ( words)

IR systems measure temperature empirically at the PCB or component, whereas hot air systems measure hot air temperature near the hot air exit source. This makes for a more-exacting profile based on achieved component temperature. In addition, IR heat sources require little tooling for specific BGA sizes. Another advantage is the ability to easily take in-process temperature data of the IC for each reflow operation. However, the primary advantage to the IR heating is the ability to not disturb very small components as no turbulent air flow exists along with the heating source.


Figure 3: Focused IR heating technology for PCB rework.

While the infrared heating source has some distinct benefits over the hot air systems, it too has some shortcomings as a reflow source for BGA rework. There are still some underpowered IR heaters on the market which means that the rework process cycle time is much longer than a properly-designed nozzle and hot air system. This means that for very large boards such as servers, backplanes and other high current-carrying PCBs, the IR heat source may not be sufficient. The user needs to be aware that IR systems using medium wavelength IR resulting in darker-colored components have a different absorption of heat energy than light-colored components. In some cases, this means that the user must employ an ESD-safe black tape to make sure the component heats up to the right heat energy levels. Process control can be difficult with infrared heating as the absorbency spectrum and therefore reproducibility from component to component and board to board results can be an issue.

Both hot air and IR heat sources have their place in PCB rework with specific choices of rework heat source dependent upon the application at hand.

This article was originally published in the November 2017 issue of SMT Magazine.



Suggested Items

Juan Arango on Koh Young’s New U.S. Headquarters

10/27/2019 | Andy Shaughnessy, I-Connect007
At a recent open house, Managing Director Juan Arango talks about his role in the company’s transition from their Arizona facility to a new headquarters located outside of Atlanta, Georgia. Juan details many of the benefits customers can expect, including brand new spaces dedicated to customer demos as well as training.

SMTAI 2019: Chris Bastecki on Low-temperature Solder Challenges and Products

10/14/2019 | Real Time with...SMTAI
Chris Bastecki, director of global PCB assembly at Indium Corporation, discussed challenges of low-temperature solder and the company's new product, Durafuse LT, which provides novel properties and reliability.

Real Time with... SMTAI 2019 Video Interviews

10/09/2019 | Real Time with...SMTAI
The SMTA International Conference and Exhibition 2019, which took place September 22–26, 2019, at the Donald E. Stephens Convention Center in Rosemont, Illinois, concluded successfully. For those of you who were not able to make it to the show, catch our video interviews with the movers and shakers of the electronics industry. We've updated our video presentation for a better experience for our users, so check it out!

Copyright © 2019 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.