Evaluating the Impact of Powder Size and Stencils on Solder Paste Transfer Efficiency

Reading time ( words)

Building upon an earlier study which focused on solder paste powder size, room-temperature aging and PCB pad and aperture designs, this study continues to investigate powder mesh size, but also examines stencil surface treatments and stencil foil tension. The goal of the study was to identify and rank the variables that provided the most improvement in repeatability, transfer efficiency and print definition for fine pitch printing. The results showed that nanocoating, powder type and tension rank highest to lowest in terms of their effect on print quality, and that high tension should be further studied to better understand where it makes the most significant impact.

Previous work revealed that:

a. reducing solder powder mesh size provides a modest improvement in print consistency and transfer efficiency for certain aperture designs

b. reducing solder powder mesh size may reduce solder paste useful life and increase process variables under certain conditions

c. pad and aperture design are the most significant variables in improving solder paste transfer efficiency when using high-quality, nanocoated stencils at standard mounting tensions


Figure 1: Jabil solder paste evaluation board.

This study adds to the database the effect of nanocoating and mounting tension on print quality, bringing a new arm to the experiment by printing unaged Type 4 (T4) and Type 5 (T5) solder pastes with similar stencils; however, one stencil is coated with a commercial polymer nanocoating and the other is uncoated and mounted at high tension. For reference, “standard” mounting tension is about 35N/cm, whereas “high” tension is 50N/cm or higher.

Theoretically, higher mounting tension should create Smore precise deposits because the foil will not deflect or reverberate as much during the separation phase of the printing process compared to a lower tension foil.

Experimental Method

Test Vehicle

The test vehicle (TV) selected for the print study was the Jabil Solder Paste Evaluation Board 2 that is commercially available from a leading dummy component and test kit supplier. The TV shown in Figure 1 provided an exceptionally thorough and detailed analysis in our earlier study and was used again in this study to provide continuity in data collection and analysis.

Features included:

• Print-to-fail (PTF) patterns with combined pad sizes ranging from 3 to 15mils with shapes including circular, square and rectangular pads, defined with both copper (NSMD) and solder mask (SMD)

• 0.4 and 0.5 mm BGA patterns.

• Markings on the PCB are etched in copper rather than silkscreened with ink to eliminate the standoff effect of PCB nomenclature


Table 1: Pad sizes, area ratios and theoretical aperture volumes for 4mil (100μm) foil.

The smallest feature size printed in this study was 6 mil (150 μm) which produces an area ratio of 0.38 using a 4 mil (100 μm) stencil. The smallest feature size reported is 8 mil (200 μm), as the variation increases dramatically below this threshold, due in part to the low ARs and in part to measurement error. The TV used in this arm of testing was from the same production lot that was used in the previous study. The data was collected using a new panel for each print. No PCBs were cleaned and reprinted. The pad and aperture sizes, area ratios and theoretical volumes are shown in Table 1.


The stencils employed current state-of-the-art technology which would typically be used for the fine feature applications that demand finer powder solder pastes. They were cut from pre-mounted name-brand stainless steel on a modern, diode laser by a high-quality, US-based stencil supplier. One stencil foil was pre-mounted at high tension; the other at standard. The stencil supplier then applied a proprietary polymer nanocoating to the standard tension stencil. The SPI results from each stencil were compared to those in the existing database from the previous study. All apertures were sized one to one (1:1) with the test pads, with no reductions on any apertures.

Laboratory Equipment & Print Parameters


Figure 2: AIM applications laboratory manager reviews test setup.

The test equipment included a DEK Horizon screen printer, Parmi Sigma X SPI machine and ASH video microscope in the AIM Applications Laboratory located in Juarez, Mexico. The test area is climate controlled and can be manipulated to simulate production environments around the globe. Test conditions were optimized at 25.4°C (77.4°F) at 59% RH for these tests and recorded twice daily.

The facility is staffed with full-time SMTA-certified process engineers with over 50 years of combined experience in SMT assembly processes. Figure 2 shows the laboratory manager preparing the DEK Horizon printer and Parmi Sigma X SPI machine for the test run. The print parameters were as follows:

• Squeegee: 14” (355 mm) 60° angle DEK OEM

• Squeegee speed: 40 mm/sec (~1.6 in/sec)

• Squeegee pressure: 10 kg (~1.5 lb./in on 14” blades)

• Separation speed: 1 mm/sec (~0.040 in/sec)

• Separation distance: 3 mm (~120 mils)

• Under wipe sequence: Wet-Vacuum-Dry (WVD), using DEK EcoRoll wiper paper and AIM DJAW-10 solvent. Stencils were automatically underwiped before the first print of each set of five.

A dedicated flat tooling support block was used to provide solid support for the PCB, and new squeegee blades were used for the tests.

Automatic Solder Paste Inspection

SPI inspection parameters were modified to improve the accuracy of the measurements. Typically, a 30-40 μm measurement threshold is used in production environments to eliminate noise from PCBs’ topographical features like silkscreen markings, mask over trace, etc. Because the design of this TV limits topographical feature noise, it enabled a 15 μm measurement threshold, to improve measurement fidelity and aid in detecting subtle variations in print behavior.


Suggested Items

Tips to Improve Soldering Tip Life and Reduce Cost

10/10/2018 | Thermaltronics
Whether in production, or repair and rework, the cost of soldering iron tips can be easily overlooked, but with today’s requirement for higher temperatures in lead-free solder applications, the consumption of tips has dramatically increased. This fact, combined with changes in tip design to meet the higher thermal load requirements, has also resulted in escalating tip costs, making tip care a high priority.

What SMT Component Shortages Mean for Design and Manufacturing Engineers

09/13/2018 | Russell Poppe, JJS Manufacturing
Much has been written about the increasing shortages of electronic components such as MLCCs, chip resistors and other semiconductor devices. And the manufacturing industry is now seeing price increases and greatly extended lead times. It seems the situation is likely to get rapidly worse rather than better. What can we do? Read on.

RTW NEPCON South China: Mycronic Discusses Industry 4.0

09/12/2018 | Real Time With... NEPCON South China
At the recent NEPCON South China 2018 event in Shenzhen, Clemens Jargon, VP for Global Dispensing and Asia at Mycronic, discusses I-Connect007's Edy Yu the challenges that customers face on their journey towards Industry 4.0, and how Mycronic is addressing these issues. From jet printing to solder paste inspection, to pick-and-place, Jargon talks about their total solutions that aim to help customers take their production to the next level.

Copyright © 2018 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.