-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- smt007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueIPC APEX EXPO 2024 Pre-show
This month’s issue devotes its pages to a comprehensive preview of the IPC APEX EXPO 2024 event. Whether your role is technical or business, if you're new-to-the-industry or seasoned veteran, you'll find value throughout this program.
Boost Your Sales
Every part of your business can be evaluated as a process, including your sales funnel. Optimizing your selling process requires a coordinated effort between marketing and sales. In this issue, industry experts in marketing and sales offer their best advice on how to boost your sales efforts.
The Cost of Rework
In this issue, we investigate rework's current state of the art. What are the root causes and how are they resolved? What is the financial impact of rework, and is it possible to eliminate it entirely without sacrificing your yields?
- Articles
- Columns
Search Console
- Links
- Events
||| MENU - smt007 Magazine
IPC High-reliability Forum and Microvia Summit Review, Part I
July 25, 2019 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
The IPC High-Reliability Forum and Microvia Summit—held in Hanover, Maryland, May 14–16, 2019—focused on IPC A-610 Class 3 high-reliability electronics for critical military, aerospace, automotive, and medical applications required to function without interruption for an extended lifetime where downtime was not acceptable. The event covered a broad range of topics related to reliability and provided interactive opportunities to share expert knowledge and experience in determining and understanding the causes of failure and selecting the best design rules, materials, processes, and test methods to maximise product reliability.
John Bauer, STC program manager with Collins Aerospace, was the keynote speaker. The theme of his presentation was designing for reliability: “You’re only as strong as the weakest link.” And in this context, via holes constituted the “weakest link.”
Referring to the myriad of electronic systems and devices used in commercial aircraft, Bauer commented that products were expected to last upwards of 20 years in the field, enduring operational temperature extremes between -40 and +85°C. He reviewed the accelerated thermal cycling and thermal shock test methods used as indicators for field reliability and described in detail the qualification testing of via interconnects by monitoring change in resistance. By disciplined supply chain management—especially the use of qualified materials and the meticulous selection of PCB vendors with defined technology capability combined with accredited quality systems and reliability testing procedures—the incidence of confirmed microvia defects had been reduced to zero in 2017 and 2018 for a total of over a billion microvias purchased over those two years.
Next, Bauer showed many real examples of microvia failure. His list of root causes included aspect ratio greater than 1:1, debris entrapment from secondary machining operations, inadequate cleaning, unauthorised process changes, overheating of target pads during laser drilling, inadequate throwing power of copper plating, and poor supplier selection.
So, what were the attributes of reliable microvias? Bauer recommended aspect ratios of less than 0.75:1, ablated diameters greater than 0.005”, target pad diameters greater than 0.012”, and two-ply construction with spread-glass prepreg. He recommended choosing the most reliable from this list to suit the particular end-use application: open-plated microvias, full-plated single layer microvias, staggered microvias, two-stacked microvias, and three-stacked microvias (based on his experience and in descending order of reliability).
Bauer then showed test results demonstrating the comparative reliability of different via structures from qualified PCB suppliers followed by examples of stacked microvia and microvia-on-buried-via structures that had failed qualification. Variables that significantly affected reliability were via-fill material selection, tin-lead versus lead-free reflow, and the diameter and aspect ratio of buried vias.
Yaad Eliya, CTO of PCB Technologies in Israel, also reviewed new applications and innovative solutions for RF microwave. In his presentation, he discussed the benefits of incorporating air-cavity and air-tunnel technologies in PCB designs for radar systems operating at GHz frequencies. Instead of designing multiple systems each with a discrete frequency, these technologies enabled a significant increase in bandwidth such that a single module could cover multiple radar signatures as well as saving weight and cost.
Eliya went on to compare the attributes of standard materials, such as low-Dk FR-4 laminates, proprietary woven glass-reinforced hydrocarbon-ceramic laminates, and flexible polyimide laminates with enhanced materials—including PTFE-ceramic laminates, proprietary “very low-loss” laminates, fluoropolymer-polyimide composite flexible laminates, and glass-microfibre-reinforced PTFE composites. He also discussed the effects of raw materials, fillers, glass styles, and copper foil surface roughness on high-frequency performance and signal integrity before offering practical guidance on design rules for soft materials and embedded-component procedures. Eliya then gave general guidelines for selecting heat dissipation solutions and recommended using highly accelerated thermal stress testing for material and process optimisation.
Terry Munson, founder and president of Foresite Inc., explained that a conductive anodic filament (CAF) failure was an electrical short occurring inside the PCB as a result of a conductive filament forming in the laminate dielectric material between two adjacent conductors under a DC electrical bias and humidity. His presentation demonstrated that resin starvation in the glass weave at a via location could allow plating chemistry to penetrate the weave and create the conditions for an inner layer CAF short under normal operating power. The principal structural difference between CAF and dendrite growth was that the former was internal and the latter external.
External dendrite shorting could result from no-clean flux residue incompletely heat-activated, water-soluble flux not properly cleaned, condensing water between conductors, contamination from outside sources, or fabrication residues on the PCB and components. Munson set out to find answers to the logical questions. Do these contaminants and moisture pass into the PCB inner layer and cause the same issue? How do moisture and corrosive contaminants get into the weave of the board? Wouldn’t the outside create shorts on top of the mask or under the mask first? If the corrosive residue cane in though the via, wouldn’t there be signs of the copper barrel corroding?
Using a series of case-history examples illustrated by a combination of optical microscopy and X-ray with scanning electron microscopy and energy-dispersive spectroscopy, Munson demonstrated the effects of resin starvation in the laminate, rough drilling of via holes, and surface contamination from etch and rinsing processes during inner layer fabrication on the formation of CAF shorts. Furthermore, he believed that CAF failures resulting from fabricator process control issues might only show up on a specific panel in a stack of pressed panels.
Dr. Mike Bixenman, VP and CTO of Magnalytix—a joint venture between KYZEN Corporation and STI Electronics—was an advocate of surface insulation resistance (SIR) testing as a means of gathering real-time objective evidence of cleanliness for determining the reliability of electronic assemblies and mitigating the risk of failure. Cleanliness was a key reliability factor as functionality increased, designs became denser, component packaging clearances became smaller, and operating environments became harsher.
How could ionic cleanliness be meaningfully measured? The industry had for many years relied upon resistivity of solvent extract (ROSE) testing, but it has now been recognised that this method is obsolete and is no longer considered an acceptable basis for qualifying a manufacturing process. Amendment 1 to IPC J-STD-001G was a major revision of the J-STD-001 cleanliness requirements and changed how the industry would address future cleaning and residue requirements. For high-reliability assemblies, soldering and cleaning processes would be qualified in terms of acceptable levels of flux and other residues as determined just prior to application of conformal coating. “Acceptable” and “unacceptable” levels of residues on production hardware would be determined, and the risks associated with contamination identified, analysed, controlled, and monitored to eliminate risks or mitigate their effects.
Bixenman also discussed humidity-related failure modes where trapped residues left from soldering and handling could result in dendritic growth, conductive anodic filament formation, electrochemical migration, migration under conformal coating, and gas corrosion, especially under harsh climatic conditions. He described the principal elements of an effective SIR test system designed for use at the production floor. These included a certified high impedance meter and power supply, matrix switching cards for eight test board slots (each with four channels per board), highly shielded cables for very low noise and crosstalk when measuring high SIR values, a real-time user interface run live during testing with high processing speed, outputs for analytics and data, and facilities for SPC and internet-enabled report generation with the ability to fully control the environmental chamber.
The SIR test method was effective at testing for residue effects, incoming bare board cleanliness, material investigations and qualifications, and the prediction of long-term failure mechanisms. The system Bixenman described could be used for on-site process characterisation, process development, and process optimisation, and he showed many application examples in PCB system design, process development, process control, and product acceptance.
Watch this space for Part II of this review.
Suggested Items
Trouble in Your Tank: Supporting IC Substrates and Advanced Packaging, Part 5
03/19/2024 | Michael Carano -- Column: Trouble in Your TankDirect metallization systems based on conductive graphite or carbon dispersion are quickly gaining acceptance worldwide. Indeed, the environmental and productivity gains one can achieve with these processes are outstanding. In today’s highly competitive and litigious environment, direct metallization reduces costs associated with compliance, waste treatment, and legal issues related to chemical exposure. What makes these processes leaders in the direct metallization space?
AT&S Shines with Purest Copper on World Recycling Day
03/18/2024 | AT&SThe Styrian microelectronics specialist AT&S is taking World Recycling Day as an opportunity to review the progress that has been made in recent months at its sites around the world in terms of the efficient use of resources:
Matrix to Exhibit at IPC APEX EXPO 2024 in Anaheim, CA
03/05/2024 | MatrixMatrix will be exhibiting at IPC APEX EXPO 2024, to be held on April 9-12, 2024, at the Anaheim Convention Center, Anaheim, CA.
The Chemical Connection: Getting to Know Your Vendor
02/16/2024 | Don Ball -- Column: The Chemical ConnectionAfter working for a capital equipment supplier for almost 50 years, I’ve found that the most important part of getting to know your vendor is good communication among all parties. While contact between fabricators of a constantly changing product line and the designers of those products may occur daily or weekly, conversations between you and your equipment supplier may be years apart. That lengthy gap often means that previous contacts may have been promoted, retired, or moved on to other opportunities. You may have also migrated to a new supplier with whom you have little or no history. In either case, you will be interacting with someone you are unfamiliar with (as they are with you). Therefore, it is essential for both sides to communicate clearly so expectations will align.
EIPC Winter Conference 2024, Day 2: A Closer Look at Global Trends
02/14/2024 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007The opening session of the second day’s conference proceedings focused on global PCB trends and was introduced and moderated by Dr. Michele Stampanoni, vice president of strategic sales and business development at Cicor Group in Switzerland. He opened the session with Dr. Hayao Nakahara’s knowledgeable and enlightening video presentation on the IC substrates industry.