Comparing Soldering Results of ENIG and EPIG Post-steam Exposure


Reading time ( words)

Abstract

Electroless nickel immersion gold (ENIG) is now a well-regarded finish used to enhance and preserve the solderability of copper circuits. Electroless palladium immersion gold (EPIG) is a new surface finish also for enhancing and preserving solderability but with the advantage of eliminating electroless nickel from the deposit layer. This feature has become increasingly important with the increasing use of high-frequency PCB designs whereby nickel’s magnetic properties are detrimental. We examine these two finishes and their respective soldering characteristics as plated and after steam aging and offer an explanation for the performance deviation.

Comparing the results of steam-age test data shows a clear benefit of EPIG over ENIG. After even a short duration exposure to steam, ENIG finishes failed to solder. Much longer steam exposures produced little to no effect on EPIG plated samples. Rapid oxidation of the electroless nickel phosphorous layer when stressed with heat and moisture explains the superior EPIG result.

The ability to demonstrate excellent solderability following steam exposure represents increased fabrication reliability under nonideal storage conditions.

Introduction

Assessing the solderability of a given final finish can range from a simple solder dip as coated or plated to quite complicated procedures involving the final finish type, solder alloy, flux characteristics, test preconditioning, soldering apparatus (wetting balance), and part geometries. Focusing on two types of solderable finishes and one preconditioning procedure allows the clear reporting of results and expectations that those finishes afford.

Morris, Lukaszewski, and Genthe describe a need for verification methods for accelerated testing of electronics. Specific to soldering operations, steam aging of PCBs before solder wick testing is seen as not only quick and inexpensive but also a reliable shelf-life predictor. Eight hours of steam aging is reported to be equivalent to 12 months of shelf-life exposure for tin-lead (60/40) systems only.

There are many solderable surface finishes used on copper printed circuit boards that range from thin organic coatings to heavy metal plates, such as 1–3 microns of gold plate. Plated tin-lead or molten tin-lead coatings (HASL) are early predecessors of the diversified finishes that are available today. These leaded alloys consistently show high resistance to steam aging and solder quality retention. Most other PCB coatings do not fare well after steam exposure. Currently, all other final surface finishes for PCBs fail to maintain acceptable solderability performance after one-hour steam exposure.

Of the many solderable finishes available, two are tested here. One—ENIG—has been available for over 20 years. It has a track record of robust soldering performance and is generally ascribed a 12-month shelf life before its soldering performance begins to degrade. EPIG, on the other hand, is a new finish with EPIG test results showing very good solder wetting and force values. The overall shelf life has yet to be determined. However, test results in this article comparing ENIG performance to EPIG performance under steam exposure stress will shed light on this question.

Steam exposure is not the only approach to determine how well a finish will hold up to environmental conditions. Other tests include thermal cycling, which shows the effect of multiple solder applications; real-time environmental exposure, which yields the most reliable data; and mixed flowing gas testing, a precise chamber test where gas type and concentration are stringently controlled. Meanwhile, steam exposure provides a quick, reliable, and inexpensive indicator of soldering shelf life.

To read the full article, which appeared in the September 2019 issue of SMT007 Magazine, click here.

Share




Suggested Items

SMT Tooling, PSA: 'Perfect Marriage of Innovation and Product'

10/26/2022 | Nolan Johnson, I-Connect007
Jeffrey Pulaski describes the recent partnership between SMT Tooling and PSA, which brings SMT Tooling’s innovation and PSA’s manufacturing capabilities together. Pulaski also shares news on product development, and what visitors to SMTA International can expect to see in SMT Tooling’s floor presence.

KYZEN Comes Clean For SMTAI

10/19/2022 | Andy Shaughnessy, I-Connect007
In this interview, KYZEN Executive Vice President Tom Forsythe explains his company’s plans for the upcoming SMTA International show in Minneapolis, Minnesota, Oct. 31-Nov. 3. He discusses KYZEN’s latest aqueous cleaning chemistries and the company’s focus on providing reliable cleaning equipment and accurate data for customers. "This is the latest in that expanded envelope, with better economics, and better environmental health and safety," he says. "It's all part of this trend of always trying to be a better product and deliver better value.

SMTA International Technical Conference: Trending on Topic

10/19/2022 | SMTA
One of the highlights of SMTA International is the Technical Conference, where more than 100 papers will be presented across at least 30 sessions. “Work that was delayed due to the effects of COVID has been completed and the amount of material coming from the industry is impressive,” says Julie Silk, VP of technical programs. “We have a packed conference this year in Minneapolis.”



Copyright © 2022 I-Connect007 | IPC Publishing Group Inc. All rights reserved.