Fresh Thinking on the Logistics of Laminate Distribution


Reading time ( words)

Mark Goodwin, COO of Europe and the Americas for Ventec International Group, sits down with Barry Matties to explain his approach to supply chain management, efficient distribution, and maintaining definitive product identity at every stage.

Barry Matties: Mark, I recently visited your plant in Kirchheimbolanden (“KiBo”), Germany and was very impressed with the operation from the point of view of logistics. I also had some very interesting conversations with Frank Lorentz, general manager at the facility. There’s a lot of opportunity for the whole concept of logistics in the operation that you’re running.

Mark Goodwin: In terms of logistics, this is a question of systems for us and links into traceability. There’s the physical movement of material and customer service, of course, but just as important are all of those additional benefits relating to service levels and the ability to provide detailed traceability. We have a lot of ongoing investment in our ERP system. For us, it’s a logistics management system that is all about material control. We are already barcoding all of our materials packaging on the way into our stock and on deliveries to our customers in terms of labeling, and we’re now looking at ways of physically marking the material. We already have the capability to etch a QR code onto copper and read it on a scanner or a mobile phone. And we’re going to have QR selection of material and QR control along the whole process inside Ventec with the potential for customers to use it in their own process and gain the benefits as well.

Everybody thinks the laminate business is straightforward. You have copper-clad plastic, and it gets cut up. What could be simpler? But one piece of copper-clad plastic looks much like another piece of copper-clad plastic; it could be 0.2 millimeters, 0.25, or 0.3 And when you’re handling a lot of materials, things could easily go wrong unless you have systems in place. Our objective is to move this control away from reliance on people, who are fallible, to a computer system-driven approach to ensure accuracy even when operating at a fast pace. Getting system control of material identification is key for this, but then there’s also the wider concept of product substitution and counterfeiting that goes on in the world, and controlling and proving provenance of materials throughout the supply chain into our customers warehouse, and even beyond to their customers; we’re thinking about that, too.

There have been instances where materials and components have proven to have been subject to unauthorized material substitutions or even suspected as counterfeits. With the Certificate of Conformance (C of C) paperwork, and with our records of sales and deliveries, we have full traceability, ensuring our customers can be sure when the material is delivered that it is what they requested, but this is not in anything like real-time. By the time it’s identified, it’s already a problem; we are looking at ways to change that.

Matties: I would also think that, depending on the critical nature of the end product, there has to be a thorough front-end inspection if it’s going into a high-reliability situation, for example, because you can’t have this failing.

Goodwin: Ventec works entirely with its own distribution channel. I’m sure at the point of shipping the material that we’re shipping Ventec material because we don’t have anybody else’s material.

Matties: And that’s one of the advantages of Ventec.

Goodwin: Yes, it is a huge advantage. What happens from there on, either accidentally or deliberately, we can’t control; however, we can trace back today to the point of shipment. I have that level of traceability already, without too much difficulty, but after the event. We know what we delivered, where to, and in what quantity. We need feedback on certain information to confirm this, but we can demonstrate traceability to this point with current paper-based systems. There’s work going on in IPC about material counterfeiting, but we have to be careful with that terminology in the laminate business. What does counterfeiting mean? I’m not convinced people are out there making a Ventec lookalike laminate.

Some PCB shops may say laminates are basically the same and interchange them—using IPC slash sheet numbers, for example—because they don’t have the Ventec or other manufacturers’ material in stock. I am sure this has happened historically in the FR-4 business for years, because in that business, it mostly doesn’t matter, and without using something like an FTIR scan, the OEM could not tell which manufacturers’ material was used. And if you’re dealing with one of the more professional manufacturers of FR-4, frankly speaking, everybody makes a good product.

Most of the differentiation comes down to service, logistics, price, etc. However, in the newer materials, such as IMS for thermal management and our tec-speed, high-speed, low-loss, and high-frequency product ranges, the material is a component in the system. They’re not just a physical carrier of the interconnect anymore; they are a component that delivers critical performance in the end product, and that’s where it’s becoming critical to both avoid and catch any material substitution.

We have to think about this topic and how to give people confidence. One thing you can be confident about with Ventec is if you talk to Ventec in Europe, it’s connected back to manufacturing sites in Asia with nobody in between; they’re all Ventec people. It’s a secure pipeline to market; if mistakes happen after that, it’s mostly down to process or human error. When one piece of laminate looks very much like another piece of laminate, you need to have solutions in place to help differentiate and ensure correct selection. This could be a human-readable inkjet marking at its simplest, but I am more interested in a computer-readable solution that is less easy to implement and much harder to remove than ink, so a robust, system-readable solution.

My plan is to give the customer a way of checking the physical material when they pick the stock from their inventory with computer verification, potentially including a feedback loop to our lot number database as it goes into and through their process. By removing the reliance on a paper trail, we remove reliance on operator accuracy. And for laminate, I already have a small-scale solution, which we are working to scale up.

We’re taking it one step at a time. We can do it on copper-clad material, and even unclad laminate. However, prepreg is another challenge, and the result on laminate is readable on a mobile phone, so it can be quickly checked in the field without any special equipment and is small enough not to take up too much real estate, which is a cost, of course.

Matties: That’s important.

Share

Print


Suggested Items

Aurora Circuits on Ultra-Heavy Copper PCBs

08/03/2020 | Dan Beaulieu, D.B. Management Group
It’s always fun to talk with a company that can do something different—in this case, ultra-heavy copper PCBs, meaning over 20-ounce copper. Wanting to know more, Dan Beaulieu talked to Aurora Circuits Director of Business Development Thad Bartosz.

Rethinking Captive Manufacturing

07/30/2020 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
Alex Stepinski and Whelen Engineering caught everyone’s attention a few years ago when they opted to make their own PCBs in an innovative captive facility: GreenSource Fabrication. Now, with the recent purchase of an equipment manufacturer, Alex is helping to design whole factory solutions for OEMs who are interested in bringing PCB fabrication in-house.

A Year in Review: Cultivate New Opportunities in Crisis, Start Fresh

07/16/2020 | I-Connect007 China Team
Recently, the China Electronic Circuit Industry Association (CPCA) invited Dr. Shiuh-Kao Chiang from Prismark to present an online video report regarding the current and future impact of the current epidemic on the global electronic circuit industry. The I-Connect007 China Team attended the presentation, and the following report summarizes some of Dr. Chiang’s remarks.



Copyright © 2020 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.