Doug Pauls Explains Ion Chromatography


Reading time ( words)

Residues from manufacturing operations may adversely impact the reliability of printed circuit assemblies in the field. But not all residues are harmful or detrimental: What is critical is to understand what kinds of residues are present and in what amounts. ROSE (Resistivity of Solvent Extract) techniques have been used as a measure of ionic contamination by bare board manufacturers and assemblers since the 1970s, and there is a huge installed base of ROSE test equipment. But does ROSE testing give sufficient information about the nature and origin of the residue in the context of present-day electronics manufacturing? Ion chromatography offers a more precise and selective analytical technique, but how does it work and how can it be used to determine electronic cleanliness? What ion-chromatography-based specifications exist and how they were derived, and how you would use this tool for process troubleshooting and optimization?

Principal Materials and Process Engineer at Rockwell Collins and Chair of the IPC Cleaning and Coating Committee, Doug Pauls drew upon his 25 years' experience in the use of ion chromatography for electronics assembly improvement to answer these questions, in a webinar presented on behalf of SMART Group and moderated by Bob Willis.

Pauls began by reviewing the status and limitations of ROSE testing, and discussed the reasons why the industry should not continue to use ROSE for acceptance testing against a background of almost everyone having the equipment for a test that was called up in the majority of purchasing specifications, that was easy to carry out, and easy to pass. But the methods and pass-fail criteria came from an era where high-solids rosin fluxes and CFC solvent cleaning were standard, and these were no longer relevant. Present-day assemblies were vastly different in component density, complexity, materials of construction, and manufacturing methods.

He drew attention to IPC-TR-583 ‘An In-Depth Look at Ionic Cleanliness Testing’, published as long ago as 1993 but still applicable, which had concluded that ROSE tests tended not to be repeatable or reproducible, the "equivalency factors" were not valid and that the equipment should not be used for product acceptance but only for the process control purposes for which it was originally intended. An example he gave from his own production facility was when a sudden increase in the result of routine ROSE testing gave early warning of a failure in the works DI water plant. But in general, his comment was: "You may know something is making the extract solution conductive, but you don’t know what. Many modern contaminants won’t even make an ionic cleanliness tester twitch! How comfortable are you using reliability criteria developed in the 1970s? You need a tool that is much more specific on the soils on your product. ROSE is a broad bladed axe – ion chromatography is a surgeon's scalpel!"

Alphasoup.jpgTo explain how ion chromatography worked, he began with one of his renowned graphic analogies: this time vegetable beef soup, consisting of macaroni letters, beef, carrots, tomatoes, potatoes, broth, salt and spices, and a magical strainer with which he could separate all the individual constituents and examine them. In this way, he could determine the main differences between Doug Pauls’ soup and Bob Willis’ soup. But even if they contained the same proportions of macaroni letters, beef, carrots, tomatoes and potatoes, Bob's soup tasted different to Doug’s soup, and Doug’s primary magical strainer was unable to separate the components of the broth, so he needed an even finer magical strainer to resolve the salt, pepper, other spices and Bob’s secret ingredients. (Edible flowers, Willis later admitted…)

Back to the reality of ionic residues on printed circuit assembles: the extract solution was essentially a chemical soup of residues that needed to be separated out into individual species for identification and quantification, and this was achieved in the ion chromatograph by a specialised fractionating column and conductivity detector. Different columns and eluents were used for anions and cations, and the equipment worked at very high pressure although the pipework was of capillary diameter so actual flow-rates were very small, typically 0.25 ml/minute. Using his own system as the example, Pauls explained the function and contribution of each major component. "It might look complicated, but if you appreciate how a domestic plumbing system works, you will have no difficulty in understanding the basic principles." The sample, typically 10 microlitres, was introduced, either manually or with an autosampler, into a sample loop, and a multi-position valve admitted it to the separation column via a guard column designed to protect the separation column from any accidental gross contamination - it could cost $2000 to replace - where it was absorbed on the ion-exchange medium.

Share

Print


Suggested Items

Names to Know: Up and Comers in U.S. Congress

08/14/2019 | Ken Schramko, IPC Senior Director, North American Government Relations
When major news occurs in the U.S. Congress, you usually hear the names of top congressional leaders such as House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) or Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY).

Conformal Coating Selection: Conventional vs. Two-part

08/14/2019 | Phil Kinner, Electrolube
As assemblies become more densely populated, and housing/casing designs become more permeable to save weight, the use of conformal coatings is essential to protect the assembly from its operating environment and ensure acceptable reliability for the application intended, especially when operating in hostile environments.

IEEE's Future Directions Programs Target Reliability

08/13/2019 | Dan Feinberg, Technology Editor, I-Connect007
Dan Feinberg speaks with Kathy Grise, IEEE Future Directions senior program director, at the AWE conference recently in San Jose, California. In this excerpt, Dan and Kathy discuss the importance of reliability, blockchain, recruiting younger generations, etc.



Copyright © 2019 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.