Fresh PCB Concepts: Does the Assembly Process Damage a PCB? (Part 1—Soldering)

David_Duross_NCAB.jpg

A few years ago, a colleague contacted me with a question: “How can we solder boards with a Tg of 180°C or even 200°C at temperatures of 225-245°C without damaging the board? Even with leaded boards the peak reflow temperatures are way above the board’s Tg. How is this possible?”

The answer is simple. Every time a printed circuit board is exposed to soldering temperatures it is damaged. This is the case not only for lead-free soldering applications but also for eutectic soldering consisting of tin-lead. The Tg is one of several parameters to be aware of. In the case of Tg, many designers refer to the value as a gauge of stability. A high Tg product has less thermal expansion in the Z-axis. Below Tg the laminate epoxy resin system is hard and solid. You can expect the rate of thermal expansion to be around 25 ppm/°C. Above Tg the epoxy becomes soft and pliable. When the epoxy becomes soft and pliable the rate of expansion can be up to 10 times the expansion rate compared to the expansion rate below the Tg value. Tg 180°C material is more stable than Tg 140°C laminate due to the 40 degree range of the epoxy system remaining hard and solid.

The parameter that best determines when the board starts to take thermal damage is referred to as the maximum continuous operating temperature (MOT). MOT is a parameter that is tested for and certified by Underwriters Laboratories (UL). A bare board manufacturer shall build a qualification sample through their most destructive process and submit it to UL for compliance testing. A board with a certified MOT of 130°C shall take no thermal damage in the field when exposed to temperatures at or below 130°C. Above the MOT value the epoxy resin the PCB is made from starts to breakdown at the molecular level. As the molecular bonds break due to heat stress, energy is released. The released energy appears as smoke. The higher the temperature the board is exposed to the faster the damage occurs. Damage is cumulative.

Dry baking moisture out of a PCB is a good example of the damage threshold. For a PCB, the dry bake temperature must be above the boiling point of water (100°C) but below the MOT. Theoretically speaking, you can dry bake a board with a MOT of 120°C at 110°C for a year and the epoxy resin the PCB is made from shall take no thermal damage. Likewise, if the dry bake temperature is 121°C the epoxy resin would start taking damage. Theoretically speaking at one degree above MOT it would take months to do any real damage. At 300°C the PCB is damaged so quickly that delamination occurs in less than a minute. The higher the temperature the less time it takes to burn away the epoxy resin the PCB is made from. In reality, the MOT is the tested value. The actual PCB may exceed this value by a few degrees.

Every time a printed circuit board is exposed to assembly temperatures the epoxy resin holding the PCB together takes damage. This is the case for conventional eutectic soldering temperatures as well as lead-free soldering temperatures. This is where the decomposition temperature (Td) value comes in. By definition, this is the temperature at which a 5% weight loss occurs by thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA). Decomposition is the breaking of chemical bonds in the resin system. The epoxy resin in the laminate is basically burning up. A 2% to 3% weight loss of this nature will adversely affect circuit performance. The damage caused from decomposition is cumulative. This places a limit on the number of lead-free assembly cycles at temperature on a printed circuit board.

The higher the Td the slower the rate of burn. Materials with a Td at or below 300°C are fine for eutectic tin-lead soldering. Materials with a Td above and beyond 300°C are more suited for lead-free soldering. In this case, the higher the Td value the more thermally resistant the epoxy resin is, and the higher the better. Highly rated Td material shall still burn away but at a slower rate of decay. Lead-free assembly compliant laminates are typically phenolic cured epoxy systems. Phenolic cured epoxy systems typically have a higher Td compared to the traditional dicey cured epoxy systems. It is for this reason that dicey cured epoxy systems are not considered lead-free assembly friendly.

Soldering has always done damage to printed circuit boards. Tin lead soldering hasn't been damaging enough to be a big concern at the eutectic soldering temperatures applied. Lead free soldering is and should remain a concern to everyone.

David Duross is an engineering director for NCAB Group USA.

Back

2021

Fresh PCB Concepts: Does the Assembly Process Damage a PCB? (Part 1—Soldering)

04-14-2021

Every time a printed circuit board is exposed to soldering temperatures it is damaged. This is the case not only for lead-free soldering applications but also for eutectic soldering consisting of tin-lead.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: Mitigating the Increasing Prices of PCBs

03-18-2021

By now, you might have noticed that the cost of PCBs is increasing. What’s worse is that there are also supply chain issues causing additional delays on PCBs. You can’t redesign every board in order to reduce cost. Instead, try these tips to help you reduce manufacturing costs.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: UL Certification for the Safety of PCBs

02-18-2021

Security is essential in the electronics industry. It is vital that users can rely on the finished products when considering factors such as fire and electrical safety, which means that both the PCB and the materials they contain must measure up to the highest standards. To ensure that the boards do conform, it has become common practice to UL certify the constituent materials or the PCB itself. In this column I am going to discuss UL certification, what’s involved and why you need it.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: RF PCB Designs–Challenges, Solutions and Tips

01-14-2021

Today, RF circuitry is crammed into a large variety of commercial products. Most of these are handheld wireless devices for medical, industrial, and communications applications. There are also applications in a variety of fields that are migrating from desktop models to become portable communications units.

View Story
Back

2020

Fresh PCB Concepts: How 5G is Influencing PCB Technology Trends

12-17-2020

We have all heard about the Internet of Things (IoT) and artificial intelligence (AI). In combination with the increased data transfer rates available through 5G, they can open up a whole new level of connectivity and communication between devices and things.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: Finding and Qualifying a Long-Term Partner

11-05-2020

Finding the right factories is not an easy task. Anyone can take customers’ files and send them to whichever factory is available. But what guarantees does the customer have that the factory used is reliable in producing the design? Ruben Contreras details how to find and qualify a long-term partner.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: 4 Characteristics to Consider When Selecting PCB Base Materials

10-08-2020

Selecting the correct material is critical if you want your circuit board to survive the assembly process or come out of the assembly process in good condition. Jeffrey Beauchamp explains the four main characteristics from the IPC-4101 material specification that are critical in finding the performance of your base material.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: Advantages of Application-Engineered PCBs

09-17-2020

When working with your PCB supplier, do you have a dedicated engineering resource to help with the design of your PCB before fabrication? How about a resource that has experience and knowledge about the different applications for PCBs? Jeffrey Beauchamp explains how this is one of the most important and valuable factors when producing high-reliability PCBs, as well as what—or who—this resource could be.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: How Do You Calculate Finished Copper?

08-13-2020

How do you calculate finished copper on a PCB? This may sound simple, but Ruben Contreras has seen copper thickness called out either on the drawing or the specification, which can lead to additional EQs and, in some cases, additional costs. In this column, he explains the unintentional results that can come from misunderstanding what was requested.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: Pros and Cons of the 6 Most Common Surface Finishes

07-23-2020

There are only two different types of surface finishes for PCBs: organic and metal. Harry Kennedy describes the pros and cons of the six most common finishes on the market.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: 7 Options for Via Treatment

06-18-2020

In some cases, it's acceptable to have via holes that are completely exposed in a PCB design. But there are many others where the hole should either be covered and/or tented, or in most cases, plugged. Jeffrey Beauchamp shares seven different via hole protection types based on IPC-4761.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: Why Design and Produce PCBs Beyond Industry Specification?

05-07-2020

While questions may be an annoyance, especially when you finally have a board designed and are ready to have it built for a product, Ruben Contreras explains the importance of asking these questions and requiring specifications.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: What You Should Know About Your Board’s Solder Mask

04-09-2020

It’s a weird time we’re all in, and for most designers, work has slowed down or even stopped. While work might have slowed, now is a good time to review some of your past PCB projects to see if you can improve functionality and reduce field failures. Harry Kennedy explains how one of the simplest ways to do that is to start from the top: solder mask.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: The Benefits of Being a PCB Producer Without Owning Any Factories

03-19-2020

With NCAB's infrastructure and factory management team based in China, many customers ask why they don’t own any factories. Jeffrey Beauchamp explains how it's part of the company's long-term strategy and an advantage to our customers that they don’t own any factories. Instead, they “own” what is most important: the relationship with the factory.

View Story
Back

2019

Fresh PCB Concepts: Designing a PCB for Telecom Applications

12-12-2019

Jeff Beauchamp and Harry Kennedy discuss PCBs for telecommunication applications, including key factors to consider, such as design and material considerations. They also recommend involving your PCB supplier at the time of design to help ensure manufacturability at the lowest possible cost.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: The Current Material Situation

11-11-2019

We have all heard about the component crisis in the circuit board industry, and maybe you heard about the CCL shortage, but how many are aware of the bare board material shortage? Ruben Contreras explains the current material situation and tips to address this issue.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: Getting It Right From the Start

10-23-2019

When faced with critical time-to-market situations, it is all too easy to say, “It doesn’t matter because this is just the prototype; we can fix this later.” However, if the design is perfected from the beginning, cost savings can be applied, and manufacturability can be ensured. Perhaps most importantly, the design can be adapted with reliability in mind, leaving a seamless transition from prototype to production. How do we get it right from the start?

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: Why Material Selection Matters

10-02-2019

When you’re designing a PCB, it’s standard to call out FR-4 material, but you could be holding yourself back or even exposing your board to risk by not knowing more about PCB materials. Let’s take a small look into why. What Is FR-4, exactly? Harry Kennedy of NCAB explains.

View Story

Fresh PCB Concepts: Qualities of Medically Applied PCBs

08-26-2019

In this inaugural column from NCAB Group, Alifiya Arastu discusses details of PCBs used in medical applications, highlighting some of the differences in terms of demands and how the design must be handled.

View Story
Copyright © 2021 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.