-
- News
- Books
Featured Books
- pcb007 Magazine
Latest Issues
Current IssueThe Growing Industry
In this issue of PCB007 Magazine, we talk with leading economic experts, advocacy specialists in Washington, D.C., and PCB company leadership to get a well-rounded picture of what’s happening in the industry today. Don’t miss it.
The Sustainability Issue
Sustainability is one of the most widely used terms in business today, especially for electronics and manufacturing but what does it mean to you? We explore the environmental, business, and economic impacts.
The Fabricator’s Guide to IPC APEX EXPO
This issue previews many of the important events taking place at this year's show and highlights some changes and opportunities. So, buckle up. We are counting down to IPC APEX EXPO 2024.
- Articles
- Columns
Search Console
- Links
- Events
||| MENU - pcb007 Magazine
The Long Road to a New Standard
September 17, 2019 | Barry Matties, I-Connect007Estimated reading time: 4 minutes
Graham Naisbitt, chairman and CEO of Gen3 Systems, has spent decades leading cleanliness testing standards in a number of different standards organizations like IPC, IEC, and ISO around an assortment of testing methods, such as CAF, SIR, and even introducing a new standard this year for his own testing method—process ionic contamination testing (PICT). Naisbitt breaks down his long involvement with standards and where they stand currently.
Barry Matties: Please start by telling us about your company, Gen3 Systems.
Graham Naisbitt: For nearly 40 years, we have designed, engineered, manufactured, and distributed our test and measurement equipment into the electronics industry. Back in 2009–2010, we lost 50% revenue overnight in the downturn. It was as though somebody flicked a switch. To bolster what we’re doing in the U.K., looking for distribution of other people’s products was a natural extension, so we lined up with two or three key players. Peter Marshall, who was the chairman of the SMART Group (a trade association in the U.K.), was at a crossroads. He had his own distribution business and wanted to retire. Peter and I came to an agreement, and I took over that business, which brought in additional distribution points.
Matties: As you told me earlier, there was one event that changed the course of your work.
Naisbitt: An important point for the industry was when Dr. Wally Rubin, who was then the technical director of a company called Multicore Solders, invented no-clean flux. Wow, that was a success. But how much longer that can continue has now come into question.
Matties: Are there some practical applications that need to be addressed?
Naisbitt: Absolutely. And it’s fair to say that the vast majority of the industry is running successful no-clean processes, but it doesn’t avoid the risks associated with electrochemi cal migration notably, which takes so many different forms.
Matties: And with HDI coming into a stronger play in the market, are we seeing more failures?
Naisbitt: Yes. That was why we became involved with the conformal coating because it helped to protect the circuitry. That was the first introduction I had into what makes electronic circuits reliable. That was the key feature of our business.
I became more involved at that point to figure out how to control the production process. One of the main elements of this is that all fluxes leave residues. Surface insulation resistance (SIR) testing was developed and used to try to evaluate whether it was acceptable or not when you were using a no-clean process. With a new process and test, then you need to develop the standards. In 2007, I finally managed to publish the first meaningful documents, which was the IPC test method, and coincidentally, the IEC standard. From there, we have developed even further. The issue came into play around 2010–2012 as the industry was migrating more into increased packaging density and insulation resistance testing became a necessity if you needed to establish product reliability.
But the question that kept coming back to me is how do you control a process? You can’t use SIR testing because it takes too long and it’s too cumbersome and complex. But what you can do is use that to establish a reliable production process, and then take it from there. You need to be able to measure any mobile ionic species left on the surface that can compromise performance because if you put electricity through a product in a damp environment—and you have ionics present as well as the perfect electrolytic cell—funny stuff happens.
During this time, there was some research into this subject, and a stake was stuck in the ground that said anything above 1.56 micrograms per centimeter squared of sodium chloride equivalent is bad and below is good. Now, unfortunately, the industry started without any hesitation to adopt the term “cleanliness testing,” and it isn’t. It never was.
The challenge is the simplified ion chromatograph test, aka ROSE testing, doesn’t differentiate species; it simply looks at a value of conductivity of the solution as to whether or not it falls within acceptable limits. I have spent 25 years of my life trying to explain this to people. You have to stop thinking of it as a cleanliness test because it isn’t, but it’s an excellent method to control a process.
Around 2013, we received a call from Robert Bosch. They require Six Sigma for their production process. It’s automotive electronics that are ultra-high reliability and safety-critical. We took on the project, and in five years of work, we achieved Six Sigma verification uniquely for the first time in the history of this entire subject. To do this, the instrument needs to be sufficiently capable of detecting changes in the process as fast as possible. We use a merit-to-fit algorithm. It means that we were able to give an accurate go/no-go answer within typically three to five minutes. What we’re looking for are only those mobilizable ionic species. Cleanliness is something entirely different.
Matties: After your five years of work, the current pass-fail approach doesn’t make sense as a standard. What was the response, and how do you carry that change in the standard process to the industry and get support?
Naisbitt: There are two answers to that. One, I’m silly.
Matties: That was a short answer (laughs).
To read the full version of this article which originally appeared in the September 2019 issue of SMT007 Magazine, click here.
Suggested Items
Lockheed Martin Australia, The Department Of Defence Sign Strategic Partnership Head Contract
04/26/2024 | Lockheed MartinLockheed Martin Australia signed a landmark AUD$500 million contract with the Department of Defence to build Australia’s future Joint Air Battle Management System under project - AIR6500 Phase 1 (AIR6500-1).
SMC Korea 2024 to Highlight Semiconductor Materials Trends and Innovations on Industry’s Path to $1 Trillion
04/24/2024 | SEMIWith Korea a major consumer of semiconductor materials and advanced materials a key driver of innovation on the industry’s path to $1 trillion, industry leaders and experts will gather at SMC (Strategic Materials Conference) Korea 2024 on May 29 at the Suwon Convention Center in Gyeonggi-do, South Korea to provide insights into the latest materials developments and trends. Registration is open.
Elevating PCB Design Engineering With IPC Programs
04/24/2024 | Cory Blaylock, IPCIn a monumental stride for the electronics manufacturing industry, IPC has successfully championed the recognition of the PCB Design Engineer as an official occupation by the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL). This pivotal achievement not only underscores the critical role of PCB design engineers within the technology landscape, but also marks the beginning of a transformative journey toward nurturing a robust, skilled workforce ready to propel our industry into the future.
Real Time with... IPC APEX EXPO 2024: Going Vertical: SCHMID's Advanced Solutions for Printed Circuit Boards
04/24/2024 | Real Time with...IPC APEX EXPOEditor Marcy LaRont chats with Bob Ferguson, the president of SCHMID, about advanced solutions for PCBs and the equipment they are highlighting at this year's show. He delves into vertical no-touch handling systems and the prospect of achieving sub-10-micron lines. Inspired by SCHMID's technology, Bob expresses excitement about where the industry is today.
Big Win for Defense Production Act Budget Allocation in FY24 Budget
04/23/2024 | I-Connect007 Editorial TeamOne year ago, President Biden issued a determination that chips and packaging are critical for national security. Since that time, much work has been done to continue the conversation in Washington, elevating the importance of the entire chips value chain, and including printed circuit boards and substrates, without which chips cannot operate.