SMART Group Webinar: Advances in AOI technology
Systems for automated optical inspection (AOI) of electronic assemblies have undergone dramatic evolution and development in recent years, from very basic 2D image recognition via “2.5D” and “pseudo 3D” to full 3D techniques. SMART Group recently presented a webinar to clarify the fundamentals of AOI technology and discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the equipment options currently available. SMART Group Chairman Keith Bryant drew upon many years’ experience as a specialist in X-ray and AOI techniques to give a clear and comprehensive overview, with detailed explanations of attributes and applications.
“Through the eye of a needle” was the analogy that Bryant used to illustrate the trend in component size and spacing. Indeed the eye of a needle and the head of a pin looked huge compared with the 01005 chips he showed next to them. And when these chips were placed at 0.1 mm spacing, covering up to 83% of the local real estate, inspecting them for placement accuracy and solder joint quality became a real challenge. At the other end of the packaging scale were the Z-axis issues of inspecting BGAs and QFNs for coplanarity and PoPs for warpage.
Lots of good equipment was available for traditional inspection: Magnifiers, comparators, digital imaging devices, and video microscopes, but all depended ultimately on the human eye. “Is there a standard eye test for assembly operators?” Bryant asked. (Apparently there is in some aerospace specifications!). But in reality, the missed-defects rate was disturbingly high. The second consideration was the inconsistency of “judgement of what is acceptable.” Guidelines existed, for example IPC-A-610, but it was the operator’s interpretation that determined whether a defect was rejectable.
So what were the automated options? Bryant listed functional test of finished product, electrical test of partial or finished assemblies, in-circuit test of circuits and components, automated X-ray inspection for soldering and presence of components, AOI for soldering and components, and automatic solder paste inspection. He chose to focus on AOI for detail discussion.
First decision to be made was whereabouts in the process to use AOI most effectively--inspection of solder paste, component placement, solder post-reflow, or all three? Three machines on-line or a single machine off-line, able to perform all three functions on a sample basis? Whatever the decision, AOI would give more consistent results than the human eye, and, if used pre-reflow, would check for attributes such as component presence and position, component identity, orientation, polarity, and alignment. Most importantly in Bryant’s view, it would replace the “dangerous tweezer-people.” Post-reflow, the inspection task became particularly demanding. In Bryant’s words, “It’s hard to define a good solder joint--it’s even harder to define a good-enough solder joint!”
Bryant went on to explain the principles of AOI technology, the various illumination, image-capture, and image-analysis techniques available, their relative costs and capabilities, and the differences between the terms “2D,” “2.5D,” “pseudo 3D,” and “real 3D.” He discussed in detail the value of true z-axis information, particularly in solder paste inspection, citing the widely accepted view that over 60% of assembly defects originate from the solder paste printing stage, then showed several examples illustrating the limitations of 2D post-reflow inspection and some of the of subtle defects that could be revealed by high-end 3D systems.
“Which AOI machine matches your requirements?” he asked, and listed factors to be taken into consideration before any purchasing decision was made: Which defects appear in my factory? What is the required detection depth? Large or small batch sizes? Is my process stable? Is there an operator available for classification? Is there a programmer available for programming? What is my expected pay-back time? What is my investment or leasing budget?
Bryant’s excellent presentation--he spoke for over an hour without pausing for breath, then gave informative answers to numerous questions--was a prelude to full-day SMART Group seminar to be held at the Manufacturing Technology Centre in Coventry, UK, December 2, where delegates will have the opportunity to share the experiences of industry experts and see working demonstrations of a wide range of equipment. Anyone looking to purchase or upgrade their AOI equipment or simply to gain a greater understanding of automated optical inspection methods is invited to attend.